File a Claim
Damage to your Auto or Home
If you feel you may have sustained damage to your auto or home, we recommend having it looked at first by a reputable repair shop or licensed contractor. Let us know if you need a recommendation and we’ll be happy to refer you!
Contact your Insurance Carrier
Listed below are the contact phone numbers and websites of our insurance carriers in one easy place for you to access. Simply click on the phone number to make a call.
Questions Before Filing a Claim?
If you’re not sure whether a particular claim is likely to be covered by insurance or if you would like to discuss the potential effect on your insurance rates first, you are welcome to contact us.
AAA Auto & Home
Claims: 800-779-5630
AAA Life
Claims: 800-779-5630
Accident Fund
Claims: 866-206-5851
Ace
Business Hours: 1-800-433-0385
After Hours: 1-800-523-9254
Acuity
Claims: 800-242-7666
Emergency roadside assistance:
866-732-1466
Allstate
Phone: 877-810-2920
Roadside Assistance: 877-597-3393
American Modern
Phone: 800-375-2075
American Collectors
Phone: 800-360-2277
Amerisafe
Phone: (800) 699-6240
American Strategic Insurance (ASI)
Claims: 866-274-5677
Amtrust
Work Comp Claims: 866-272-9267
Non-Work Comp Claims: 877-207-3119
Arrowhead
Claims: 844-723-2524
Badger Mutual Insurance
Claims: 1-866-223-4371
Banner Life
Phone: 800-638-8428
Berkshire Hathaway Homestate Companies
Phone: 800-356-5750
Berkshire Hathaway Guard
Claims: 888-639-2567
Bristol West
Claims: 800-274-7865
Chubb
Phone: 800-884-3770 x4
Cincinnati
Phone: 877-242-2544
Auto Glass Claims: 877-588-4527
*Tow receipts: include name and policy #
Cincinnati Life
Phone: 888-212-6970
CNA Commercial Lines
Phone: 407-919-3688
Continental Western Group
Claims: 1-866-232-6724
Dairyland
Auto: 800-638-8763
Motorcycle: 800-833-2244
Distinguished Programs
Phone: 800-835-8179
EMC
Phone: 888-362-2255
Fax: 888-992-6132
EMC Life
Phone: 800-232-5818
Encompass
New Claims: 800-588-7400
Existing Claims: 800-262-5238
Geico
Phone: 1-866-509-9444
Genworth Life
Phone: 888-325-5433
Grange Life
Phone: 614-449-5300
Granite State Insurance Company
Phone: 800-835-8179
Great Northwest
Claims: Contact Agency 952-469-1814
Hagerty
Phone: 800-922-4050
The Hartford
Phone: 800-243-5860
Hippo
Phone: 855-999-9746
Integrity
Mutual Claims 800-348-1741
Glass Claims 888-403-2953
Jewelers Mutual
Claims Phone 1-888-884-2424
Kemper Unitrin
Claims Phone Auto 888-252-2799
Claims Phone Home 888-227-5004
Claims Fax 800-353-8444
Liberty Mutual
Mutual Claims 844-325-2467
Lincoln Financial
Phone: 800-487-1485 OPTION 4
Main Street American Group
Claims 877-425-2467
Markel
Phone: 800-362-7535
Metlife P&C
Phone: 800-854-6011
Midwest Family Mutual
Phone: 800-225-5636
Minnesota Fair Plan
Phone: 800-524-1640
Nationwide
Phone: 1-800-421-3535
Philadelphia
Phone: 800-765-9749
Progressive
Insured Claims 800-925-2886
Roadside Assistance 888-776-2778
Roadside Fax 800-876-6078
Prudential Life
Phone: 800-778-2255
RLI
Claims 800-444-0406
Safeco
Claims 800-332-3226
Roadside 877-762-3101
Selective
Phone: 866-455-9969
Towing Receipts (Include Policy # and Name) csvcenter@selective.com
SFM
Phone: 800-922-5246
State Auto
Claims: 800-766-1853
State Auto Glass Service 888-504-4527
Stillwater Insurance Group – (Fidelity)
Phone: 800-220-1351
Fax 800-491-7683
Travelers
Phone: 800-252-4633
Universal Property & Casualty
Claims: 800-218-3206
USLI
Phone: 800-523-5545 OPTION 3
Vacant Express
Business Hours 1-800-788-4780
After Hours 1-800-621-5410
West Bend
Claims/Roadside Phone 877-922-5246
Roadside Fax 262-335-7000
*Receipts can be faxed in with policy no., insured name, & phone #
West Coast Life (Protective)
Phone: 800-456-6330
Western National Insurance
Phone: 855-921-3164
Westfield
Phone: 866-937-2663
Zurich Builders Risk
Claims: 800-987-3373
Insurance companies listed on this website are not to be considered an endorsement and do not indicate an active partnership with Willow Insurance Agencies, LLC. Carrier relationships are subject to change. Availability varies by state and eligibility is subject to the carrier’s guidelines.